Skip to main content
University of Nebraska–Lincoln

Full Article

How do Managers React to a Peer’s Situation? The Influence of Environmental Similarity on Budgetary Reporting

Journal(s): Management Accounting Research
Published: September 1, 2019
Author(s): James N.Cannona, Todd A.Thornock

General Description
Dr. Todd Thornock, assistant professor of accountancy, investigates how only the knowledge of peer managers’ environments, without knowing peer actions, affects managerial behavior. Utilizing a two-part experiment in a participative budgetary reporting setting, Thornock and his co-author show managers project their decision-making process onto peer managers who share similarities in role and reporting environment. These self-projected group norms create a sense of validation. In viewing themselves as one of many, managers perceive their peers’ behavior to be a mirror image of their own desired behavior.

View Full Story

Academic Abstract
We investigate the impact the degree of similarity between one’s decision environment and that of a referent peer has on budgetary reporting. Self-categorization theory suggests that greater environmental similarity leads individuals to adjust their behavior to adhere to the social norms of peers within the same environment. We look at a reporting environment where managers can observe environmental similarity but cannot observe peers’ behavior (e.g., managers do not communicate their budget reports between departments). In this setting, we find that managers facing a similar decision environment to that of a peer manager report higher budgets than managers facing a dissimilar decision environment. Further, consistent with the idea that managers base their perceptions about the group’s social norms on their own desired behavior when peer behavior is unobservable, we find evidence that managers predict peers to report as they would, given similar environmental circumstances. Our findings provide a valuable insight into how peer environments, without knowledge of peer actions, can subtly affect managerial behavior.

Access Research Paper

Latest management Research

Supervisor Integrity Empowers Employees to Advocate for Diversity in Problematic Climates
Journal(s): Journal of Applied Psychology
Published: December 11, 2023
CoB Author(s): Brett Neely
Collective Turnover Response Over Time to a Unit-Level Shock
Journal(s): Journal of Applied Psychology
Published: December 1, 2022
CoB Author(s): Jenna Pieper